Thumbnail Feedback I'm fixing thumbnails on videos that aren't doing so great. Here is a before/after of some thumbnail work I just fixed up. How is it looking?

[Simply Simmer]

Before:
After:

 

[blackbeltsecrets]

Much better! Really love the clarify of the font - I have done something similar with mine recently and got quite a good CTR!

 

[amisclinic]

agree, thats better now

 

[VenGame]

I really like how the text is in bold and has the same type of text theme as the sims 4 text Everything looks crisp

 

[Yilk81]

The christmas lights are cool in the first one but legibility is king I believe. Must be very easy to read at a glance as that is all were doing. Glancing at all those thumbnails and judging the book by its cover.

 

[Simply Simmer]

Thanks for the feedback everyone!

 

[Stanley | Team TB]

It's always fun to look back on work like this. There was nothing wrong with the original... but you obviously grew and improved in the time since the first thumbnail. A couple very minor changes make a noticeable impact on the thumbnail's presentation. I wish we could have CTR info to go with the pics. Well done ma'am, keep up the great work!

 

[Beanie Draws]

I definitely like the second one more. it's brighter and gives more of a "Cheerful" vibe, and much easier to read text.
What kind of CTR are you getting since the update?

 

[AshrielKyle]

Nice work it looks simple but more attractive to my eyes.

 

[Brewman06]

Good work. I hate to think of what you would think of my thumbnails!

 

[IanDominicTV]

Great job on the thumbnail update!

 

[Ennsu's Vault]

The new thumbnail is better indeed ^^

 

[Varjopihlaja]

Much better and more readable!

 

[SaraSmilez]

I agree the 2nd one was a big improvement. Funny how it can take so much time figuring out these thumbnails. I like to go through and see the change in how a channels thumbnails evolve. ItΓÇÖs almost like a growing up process. If thatΓÇÖs true.... IΓÇÖm still in diapers. Nice job!
Love your comments and interaction here. If I see a thread you are on I pay more attention cuz I like what you bring!

 

[Ritik Pandey]

Lot better. 2nd one is a huge improvement

 

[Halftoon_Gaming]

Could you update on whether its given the video a boost since changing it? I like the 2nd one more, but the proof is in the pudding I suppose

 

[HenryBR]

Before: View attachment 8967
After: View attachment 8966

Definitely go with the first one. Looks more appealing than the second thumbnail in my opinion.

 

[GoHa]

Ich finde 2-tes Bild besser. Zweites Bild ist angenehmer wegen Stimmung und weniger Kontrast. Es passt zu Weihnachtsstimmung besser.

 

[Lidia S]

I honestly think both are very eye-catching! The first one is expressing more movement, so it's still a really good thumbnail. What I love about the second one though are the colors that are shining through and the fact that they match so well together.

 

[HeatherPsyD]

Wow, that was an impressive revise! I love the second thumbnail.