Thumbnail Feedback Update on my thumbnail on one of my most popular videos

[IanDominicTV]

A few weeks ago, I updated my thumbnail on my review for a headset that I bought a while ago.

Here's the old thumbnail for comparison:

Here's the new thumbnail:

Which among these 2 thumbnails stood out for you? Let me know!

 

[SILTHW]

The first one gives me more context. I wonder if adding an arrow or two pointing to the headset in the second one improves the context but keeps the simplicity?

 

[kitchen c/o ammama]

first one

agree with @SILTHW

 

[Melody Gilliland]

A few weeks ago, I updated my thumbnail on my review for a headset that I bought a while ago.

Here's the old thumbnail for comparison:

View attachment 7418

Here's the new thumbnail:
View attachment 7419

Which among these 2 thumbnails stood out for you? Let me know!

I love it, very direct to the point and eye catching

 

[Nesthead21]

The first one

 

[residentcasuals]

1st one definitely. It's not too loud in terms of detail just the right amount of information.
The 2nd one one is too bare doesn't give enough to grab my attention.

 

[Beanie Draws]

I'm not really a fan of either to be honest. Maybe the first because it gives more contect to the product (the colour and photo quality looks better too) BUT there's very little context to the point they're gamine headsets. I'd consider taking a whole new photo of the headphones ONLY (with that background colour) or maybe a side shot of the headphones much more zoomed in, and the "P600!"

Also, unfortunately the P699! Is going to limit your audience as most people are interested in a $price. so you might only be getting a specific audience.

 

[IanDominicTV]

I'm not really a fan of either to be honest. Maybe the first because it gives more contect to the product (the colour and photo quality looks better too) BUT there's very little context to the point they're gamine headsets. I'd consider taking a whole new photo of the headphones ONLY (with that background colour) or maybe a side shot of the headphones much more zoomed in, and the "P600!"

Also, unfortunately the P699! Is going to limit your audience as most people are interested in a $price. so you might only be getting a specific audience.

Thanks for the feedback, sir.

 

[kusuri]

first one

 

[Relentluss Gaming]

First one

The bright orange is great, will stick out, you have your brand in the corner, and it clearly states what the video is about, reviewing a gaming headset.

 

[AlexMagana]

The first one

 

[DCI_Dashcam]

ich w├╝rde auch das erste favorisieren, m├╢glicherweise noch einen Schatten mit rein, sonst sehr gut.

 

[IanDominicTV]

ich w├╝rde auch das erste favorisieren, m├╢glicherweise noch einen Schatten mit rein, sonst sehr gut.

Danke.

 

[Jbrame]

I agree with everyone the top one is better but might I suggest you increase the size of yourself, zoom in a bit more try to fill more of the space on the left and definitely throw in an arrow pointing to the product. Might help.