Thumbnail Feedback NEED YOUR HELP! WHICH THUMBNAIL WOULD YOU CLICK ON?

[contentkakeeda]

Hi guys, I have an entertainment channel. I am coming up with a new web series. Which Thumbnail you would prefer?

 

[Beanie Draws]

the first one could be interpreted as "clickbaity" simply because people tend to judge the use of attractive women in thumbnails as "clickbait" weather warrented or not. The second one has me curious with the whole knife thing and aggressive expression, which you might not necessarily see in the first one. The intense expression and knife alone makes me think "what on earth is going on here?" and might get me to click more.

 

[ReachRishi]

Hi guys, I have an entertainment channel. I am coming up with a new web series. Which Thumbnail you would prefer?

I would go with the 2nd one.. the face is closer and looks more inquisitive.. the first one doesnt seem like "entertainment".. seems something else.

 

[Stanley | Team TB]

I agree with the rest; the 2nd one appears to be a better thumbnail. Though I would suggest playing with your lighting/setup when attempting to take thumbnail photos. They appear a little muddy, like the pictures don't stand out. They are actually good photos, they just don't 'pop' out as much.

 

[HeatherPsyD]

The thumbnail on the right, although I can barely read the text.