Work In Progress Logo design - opinions please

[RazzBarlow]

I don't really know where this fits. It's not a thumbnail. It's not a complete video. Apologies to the moderators if I put it in the wrong spot. I would like to get other creator's opinion on this. I'm working on giving my channel a revamp to clean it up a little bit. Tell me which of these you prefer:

Option A:

Or Option B:


There is a vertical line that separates the two words, but it is hard to see on a white background. If you have dark mode turned on, it's a better representation. I like them both, for different reasons. I am leaning a bit towards one, but I don't want to skew anyone's opinion.

 

[Aaron]

I like option A but I feel like a less long version may look better? stacked instead of side?

 

[Senior Notions]

What a great channel name. "Metal" juxtaposed to "Manglers" makes me think maybe the smooth all caps san serif for "Metal" and the grungier font for "Manglers"

I agree with Aaron about stacked, maybe Manglers even slightly on top of Metal, cutting into the Metal letters.

 

[BraveStar]

I like A, both words with the same font seems to look better to me. I also agree with @Aaron, one on top of the other, maybe the bottom one sticking out a little would look good. All in all it still looks good.

 

[Beanie Draws]

The top one isn't bad, but have you tried a range of other fonts:? I don't mind it but I think it's craving a more solid sans serif font.... (sans serif means blocky without the "wings" that come out of the bottom of some of the characters) try a blockier font with that grunge style.

 

[Beanie Draws]

Oh and here's an idea. Try the two words ON TOP of each other, with a bit of a slant so it looks like the metal is crushing the manglers a bit.

 

[RazzBarlow]

I left it long so I could do this:

 

[Aaron]

I left it long so I could do this:
View attachment 3060

That banner tells me nothing about your channel though. stacked leaves room for a proper design and info to be added.

 

[Beanie Draws]

I left it long so I could do this:
View attachment 3060

DEFINITELY what you DON'T want to do. It kills your banner on mobile

 

[TubeBuddy]

DEFINITELY what you DON'T want to do. It kills your banner on mobile

That banner tells me nothing about your channel though. stacked leaves room for a proper design and info to be added.

Agreed on both of these points. Your banner should answer Who, what, when, how, and why!

Who - Who is posting on the channel?

What type of content are you posting on this channel?

When do you post your content? Monthly, weekly, daily? Etc.

How - How is your channel going to benefit ME the viewer?

Why? - Why should I subscribe to YOU specifically? Ties into the how!

 

[RazzBarlow]

DEFINITELY what you DON'T want to do. It kills your banner on mobile

I haven't looked at it on mobile. Thanks for that info. I will definitely have to make some changes.

 

[RazzBarlow]

 

[RazzBarlow]

Thanks to @Nick Nimmin for posting a very timely video today! I am much happier with this version.

 

[Ikerot]

View attachment 3120

Just checked that on mobile and it looks very compact, but readable. It tells you that there's a video every week and the three topics you do on the channel. I like it

 

[Beanie Draws]

View attachment 3120

IΓÇÖm not really a fan of ΓÇ£manglersΓÇ¥ in this to be honest. It kinda looks like a squirt of mustard. The bevel and emboss throws me off. IΓÇÖd try a few other attempts at ΓÇ£manglersΓÇ¥ but the rest of it looks great i donΓÇÖt mind the slant, just the mustard on hotdog vibe of the colour and style of manglers.

 

[EmzChad]

I like the concept but I feel like there is too much going on. I agree with Beanie with regard to manglers. I do like the stacked to the original design.

 

[Dr_Alan_Science]

Oh and here's an idea

 

[Patrick022]

How

 

[عبدالله المحبشي]

كيفواسوى شعارات