Thumbnail Feedback Choose my thumbnail! What do you think?

[gsweeting]

Hey guys I'm posting tomorrow (Wednesday) and was wondering if you have a preference for these two thumbnails?
Let me know what you think!

Thumbnail 1

Thumbail 2

 

[keithmaclroz]

I would choose the second one, I don't know why maybe because of the pretty blonde girl

 

[jawadsoomro]

Second thumbnail looks neat. First one has unclean fork and the other pumpkin photo is just average. So, second one.

 

[Alex_T]

Second one is better. Much more neat. Unfinished piece of cake on first one looks bad.

 

[Teddy Burriss]

I do not know your brand, however with that said, I share what I see:
TN#1 - seems to be about food (2 of 3 panels). Is this what your channel/video is all about, or is it more than food?
TN#2 - I wonder if you are distracting from your Brand in this TN with nearly 1/3 of your image having PRL on it. Unless your brand is Polo Ralph Lauren.

 

[gsweeting]

I do not know your brand, however with that said, I share what I see:
TN#1 - seems to be about food (2 of 3 panels). Is this what your channel/video is all about, or is it more than food?
TN#2 - I wonder if you are distracting from your Brand in this TN with nearly 1/3 of your image having PRL on it. Unless your brand is Polo Ralph Lauren.

This is so helpful thank you. I didn't think about having another brand in there!

 

[gsweeting]

@Alex_T @jawadsoomro thanks guys I didn't even think about the fork, really appreciate it

 

[UlterMonster]

I like the second thumbnail better but maybe reduce it a little bit make it less complex

 

[rosab]

I think the second one too.

 

[SilverSurferTravel]

It's a bit busy. Why not have just one image? The text could also be placed at the bottom as it obscures much of your image.